How to handle criticism at work: what to do in the hour after
The meeting ended twenty minutes ago. You are back at your screen, but the sentence is still going round: "This isn't good enough." Your face is still slightly warm, your jaw is set, and in your head you have already drafted three replies, each sharper than the last.
Here is the one sentence answer: after criticism at work, the most useful thing is neither to fire back nor to ruminate, but first to let the tension come down in your body, then to look at the comment with some kindness and keep only the part that is useful.
What happens in your body after criticism?
Criticism, even fair criticism, is a small jolt. The body reads it as a social threat: the heart speeds up, the breath rises into the chest, the shoulders close in. It is quick and automatic, and it has nothing to do with the worth of your work.
What stretches the discomfort out is usually what comes next. The mind replays the scene, hunts for the perfect line, imagines what everyone else thought. Each lap puts the body back on alert, as if it were living the moment again. The comment lasted ten seconds; the alarm can last all afternoon. It is a peculiar arrangement in which one sentence is heard once by your ears and over and over by your nervous system.
Why it pays not to reply straight away
In the minutes that follow, attention narrows towards defence. The reply that comes then is trying to protect you more than to understand. That is not a flaw, it is the body doing its job, but it is not the moment for an important conversation.
A short pause changes a great deal: a few minutes give the body time to come down, so the reply comes from you rather than from the alarm. A randomised trial published in Cell Reports Medicine (2023) compared three breathing exercises, each practised for five minutes a day over a month, with mindfulness meditation. Cyclic sighing, which lengthens the out-breath, improved mood and lowered breathing rate more than mindfulness did. The study looked at daily practice, not the minutes after criticism, but it shows that lengthening the out-breath for a few minutes is a simple, well-studied habit.
Self-compassion is not going soft
Once the tension has eased, a second temptation arrives: judging yourself. "I should have seen it coming." "I'm not up to this." We often assume this harshness is what drives improvement. The evidence suggests otherwise.
In four experiments reported in Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin (2012), researchers encouraged participants to treat themselves with compassion after a mistake or when facing a weakness. Compared with the other groups, they were more motivated to improve, and in one experiment they spent more time studying after failing a first test. Self-compassion is not complacency; it is what lets you look at a mistake without looking away.
Keep what is useful, let the rest go
Criticism often carries two things tangled together: information and emotion. The tone, the timing, the way it was said belong to the other person. The information might belong to you.
Once your body has settled, one question is enough: what in this comment helps me do better next time? Write it down in a single line. The rest you can put down. That is not indifference, it is sorting. And if your confidence tends to wobble after moments like this, the Confidence programme works on exactly that.
What this does not replace
These steps help you through ordinary criticism. They do not resolve a situation where criticism becomes repeated, humiliating or public: at that point it is no longer feedback, and it is worth raising with HR, an employee or union representative, or occupational health. If work stress has been weighing on your sleep or mood for weeks, talk to your GP.
In Soa, this moment has a place of its own: in the Pause tab of the Soa web app (coming to iOS and Android with an upcoming update), Unwind offers "After criticism", three or five minutes guided by a voice to settle the body and keep what is useful. Exercises inspired by sophrology, such as breathing, gentle movement and visualisation. Nothing to prepare. To understand how the breath works on that alarm, read our page on breathwork.
Common questions
Related reading
- 5 min readStep by step
Annual review nerves: why your memory holds on to what went wrong, and how to walk in calm
Nervous before your annual review? Why memory keeps the misses, what your body does the night before, and a three-step ritual to arrive with a clear head.
Read article - 7 min read
How Sophrology Builds Confidence from the Inside Out
Discover how sophrology builds lasting self confidence through body awareness, breathing, and visualisation. Practical exercises to quiet your inner critic.
Read article - 7 min read
Quiet cracking: when you are coming apart quietly at work
Quiet cracking is carrying on at work while your motivation and energy wear thin. How to spot it in the body, and what helps before it becomes burnout.
Read article
Practice with Soa
Put these ideas into practice with guided breathwork sessions, personalised by AI.
Free
Get your free breathing guide
Three breathing techniques to explore during a pause, delivered to your inbox.